Why Serious Composers Should Not Use AI as a Creative Tool
Why Serious Composers Should Not Use AI as a Creative Tool There is a growing pressure on composers to embrace AI as a creative partner—an insistence that resisting it is nostalgic, elitist, or fearful of progress. This framing is false. Serious composers are not rejecting technology; they are rejecting the misrepresentation of authorship . AI may be useful in processes . It can never be justified as a tool for creative composition . And the difference matters. Creation Is Not Assembly Composition is not the act of assembling pleasing patterns. It is the act of choosing —under constraint, risk, memory, failure, and intention. Every meaningful composition is the result of: lived experience aesthetic judgement physical interaction with sound cultural placement emotional consequence AI possesses none of these. It does not intend . It does not hesitate . It does not risk being wrong . It predicts. AI Is Fundamentally Unoriginal AI system...